Universal Basic Income? - Chair Adrian Alker invites your views on post Covid society

What changes do we want to see in our country as a result of this awful experience of the coronavirus?

Universal Basic Income? - Chair Adrian Alker invites your views on post Covid society

This was the invitation I gave to PCN members in the fifth of our weekly newsletters, back on April 23rd. Already we have received nineteen emails in response and we hope others may wish to take up the invitation to reflect upon what we are learning about our economy, our workforce, our environment, our priorities as a nation. I thought I would try to highlight in the coming weeks some of the wished-for changes which members have written about.

So here is one possible change!

Three members have specifically advocated the introduction of a Universal Basic Income. Even before this pandemic, millions of our fellow citizens were living very precarious lives, dependent upon a range of benefits, often pushed into poverty through insecure work in the gig economy. The government is now having to recognise that those workers in care homes and similar jobs, who are earning only a minimum wage, are the most valued in our virus-ridden world as they care for our loved ones. And yet some company executives, even at this time, are pocketing millions of pounds in bonus payments, some living in tax havens are seeking compensation for their businesses from taxpayers money.

Universal basic income when coupled with changes in the tax system to achieve a more just distribution of wealth may be an idea whose time has come – so thinks both Nicola Sturgeon and Pope Francis! Finland has experimented with the idea and currently the socialist-led Spanish government has got plans to roll out a basic income to a million of the country’s poorest households.

Presently our government, to be fair, is pouring money into job retention schemes and is having to face up to some very basic questions about how ALL its citizens can live in security. Might Universal Basic Income remove the whole strivers/skivers binary view of life? Might UBI give peace of mind, a mentally healthy outlook to those who presently lack self-worth? Might UBI approach something akin to the just and compassionate society which Jesus called the kingdom of God? UBI could provide a unconditional safety net, speaking volumes about how everyone is valued for who they are.

Lets carry on this discussion in more detail around UBI. Comments and contributions welcome!

Useful link:


Next time we will look at another of your responses to this crisis. In the meantime keep emailing us the changes you wish to see!

Adrian Alker


1 On 29/05/2020 Andy Vivian wrote:

Is UBI paid to every citizen, rich and poor?  If so why top up the income of those who have enough through their work?  Would it remove the strivers and skivers binary view?  Those with a job would still think of themselves as strivers compared with those who didn’t have a job.  Marx saw engagement in work as the key to human flourishing - OK he was thinking of work in which the individual is empowered not exploited.  But UBI might operate like in-work benefits - tempting employers to offer lower wages and less secure jobs?

2 On 08/06/2020 Nicola Phelan wrote:

Eve Poole in the Church Times is calling for UBI for one year as a recovery plan for a start. We need to follow it’s use elsewhere and seriously consider it along side measures to prevent employers abusing it. Many people have recently taken on the role of carers during the pandemic but have jobs they can’t currently do. Maybe UBI could support carers during such times allowing flexibility in the work force. Likewise illness and disability can come upon anyone and UBI could enable them to remain in some form of flexible part time work if they are able. Voluntary work could also be better valued with UBI support and be encouraged and contribute to a recognised skill set.

Comment on this entry



Your comment:

Please note all comment will be moderated by the site administrator.

Back to Blogs